This post may contain affiliate links. If you buy something we may get a small commission at no extra cost to you. (Learn more).
Proofs of a Concord Kept are the rarest items in Dark Souls 3, but there’s still a few ways to find them:
Being summoned to a different world as a Blade of the Darkmoon (online method)
Farming Silver Knights in Anor Londo (offline method)
Picking them up in Irithyll and Anor Londo (offline method)
We’ll cover exactly how to carry out each of these methods down below.
Online Concord Farming
The intended way to receive Proofs of a Concord Kept is through a very finicky online feature that causes you to be summoned into another player’s world.
This feature is very hit or miss on consoles in 2022, and completely impossible on PC, where the Dark Souls 3 servers have been shut down.
Lamenting the emptiness of Dark Souls 3’s servers in 2022
Despite the feature’s glitchiness, this is still the method I recommend for Console players, due to its relative ease.
To be summoned as a Blade of the Darkmoon, you’ll first have to equip the Blade of the Darkmoon Pledge.
When you have the Pledge equipped, you’ll see a sword and crescent moon in the top-left of your HUD
Once the Pledge is equipped, you’re playing a waiting game.
Head to the final area of Irithyll, right before the entrance to Anor Londo, and simply wait to be summoned.
You’ll probably be waiting a while for a summon due to the specific circumstances that another player has to experience for you to be called to help.
You have the best chances of being summoned around here, as this is the most popular PvP spot
When a member of the Way of Blue Covenant is threatened by another player through an invasion, they’ll be aided by a Blade of The Darkmoon that is nearby.
With enough time, this will eventually be you.
Despite the tedium of just waiting around to be summoned, the idleness of this method at least allows you to do other things while the game is open. It beats the next method, at least.
My character, an hour into waiting to be summoned
When you do eventually get summoned, you’ll be tasked with defeating the red or purple phantom that has invaded the Way of Blue member’s world.
Defeat it before it kills the Host of Embers to claim your Proof of a Concord Kept.
Fighting a purple phantom in Irithyll
Farming Silver Knights in Anor Londo
If you don’t mind an insane grind, you can also farm Proofs of a Concord Kept offline by farming Silver Knights in Anor Londo.
The first of the Silver Knights watching me from the top of the stairs
The drop rate here is insanely low, with a 1% chance to receive a Proof each time you kill a Knight.
If you want to finish farming in this lifetime, I strongly recommend you raise your item discovery stat to raise the chances of receiving a Proof.
Once you’ve gathered as much item discovery-boosting gear as you can, warp to the Anor Londo Bonfire to get started.
From the Bonfire, simply walk up the staircase to find the targets of your farm, two Silver Knights.
Take out both of these Knights and loot their corpses to hopefully receive a Proof of a Concord Kept.
The Silver Knights dropping some loot
With both Silver Knights dead, rest at the Anor Londo Bonfire to respawn them for a new round of farming.
Finding Proofs in The Overworld
As well as farming for them, you can also find two Proofs of a Concord Kept in the overworld in each playthrough.
While just two Proofs isn’t going to make much of a dent in the 30 you’ll need to get the Darkmoon Blade Miracle, every little helps when it comes to items this rare.
Warp to the Church of Yorshka Bonfire to find the first.
The Church of Yorshka Bonfire
Head forward from the Bonfire to see a corpse hunched over before an altar holding an item.
Interact with the corpse to pick up the first Proof of a Concord Kept.
The corpse in the Church of Yorshka Bonfire room
The second Proof is found shortly after the Anor Londo Bonfire, so warp there to get started.
Head up the staircase and take out the two Silver Knights, then walk through the large archway to your left to continue towards the cathedral entrance.
The archway that leads to the cathedral entrance
Enter the cathedral through the doors ahead of you, then walk up the staircase until you reach the top and find yourself in the main cathedral hall.
From here, turn left and run down these steps towards the Deacons below.
The entrance to the main hall – the Deacons are in the far distance below
Take out the Deacons on this platform, then look to your left to see a corpse slumped against the wall.
Interact with this corpse to obtain the second and final overworld Proof of a Concord Kept.
Collecting the second Proof of a Concord Kept from the corpse in the main hall
Jack is a writer from the UK that spends too much time Nuzlocking the Pokémon series. After a crushing defeat, he relaxes by rewatching Attack On Titan in the hope that it'll make the final season come out sooner - It never does.
